When it’s time to part ways with your car, one of the first questions that comes up is: should you sell it privately or go through a professional car buyer? Both options have their perks, but they also come with their fair share of headaches. Let’s walk through the differences so you can figure out what’s best for you.

Selling Your Car Privately

Selling privately means you handle everything yourself – advertising the car, meeting buyers, and negotiating the price.

The Upside

  • Potentially higher price: If you’re patient and your car is in good condition, you might get more money selling directly to another driver.
  • Full control: You decide how to advertise, what price to ask, and who you want to sell to.
  • Personal touch: Some people like knowing who’s taking over their car – especially if it’s been in the family for years.

The Downside

  • Time-consuming: Taking photos, writing ads, answering endless messages, and meeting strangers can take weeks – sometimes months.
  • No-shows and tyre-kickers: Be prepared for people who never turn up or just want to test drive without any real intention of buying.
  • Paperwork stress: From roadworthy certificates to transfer forms, you’ll need to make sure everything is in order.
  • Safety concerns: Let’s be real – meeting strangers from online listings isn’t always comfortable.

Imagine this: you list your car online for $8,000. Within a week, you’ve had 15 enquiries. Ten of them are lowball offers like “$3,000 cash today.” Two people set up times to come see it and never show up. After three weeks, you finally sell – but not without a few headaches.

Selling Your Car to a Car Buyer

A car buyer is a business that purchases cars directly from owners, often paying cash on the spot. Companies like ours specialise in buying cars quickly, no matter the make, model, or condition.

The Upside

  • Fast and hassle-free: In most cases, the sale can be completed the same day.
  • Guaranteed sale: No waiting around or dealing with time-wasters.
  • Any condition accepted: Even if your car has mechanical issues, scratches, or is unregistered, car buyers will usually still take it.
  • Less paperwork: A good car buyer will guide you through all the transfer forms and requirements.
  • Safe and simple: No strangers turning up at your home at odd hours.

The Downside

  • Lower offer: Car buyers need to make a profit, so the amount offered may be slightly less than what you could get selling privately.
  • Less room to negotiate: Unlike private sales, there’s usually not much haggling involved.

Take this scenario: you’ve got an older sedan that’s seen better days. Selling it privately might only bring in $2,500 after weeks of effort. A car buyer might offer $2,200 on the spot, cash in hand, and pick it up that same afternoon. For many people, the convenience outweighs the small difference.

Which Option is Right for You?

If you’ve got a newer car in excellent condition, and you don’t mind putting in the effort, selling privately could get you the best price. But if your car is older, damaged, or you simply don’t want the hassle, using a car buyer can save you time and stress.

A Practical Choice

At the end of the day, it comes down to what matters most: maximum dollars or maximum convenience. Selling privately might put a little more money in your pocket, but using a car buyer is faster, safer, and stress-free.

And if you’re leaning towards the easy route, we’re here to help. We buy cars across Melbourne and surrounding suburbs, offering fair cash deals and same-day removal. Whether your car’s in mint condition or barely hanging on, we’ll make the process simple.

 

If you are in Croydon, and looking to sell your car or get cash for trucks, below is the best way to visit us.

Eastern Cash For Cars
720 High St Rd, Glen Waverley, VIC 3150
(03) 7035 7830
www.easterncashforcars.com.au